W86: Offers a brighter backlight, slightly thicker case with larger buttons, and potentially better water resistance (though both ratings are disputed online). F105W: Classic icon, slimmer profile, some users prefer the muted backlight for nighttime readability.
Introduction
Imagine a watch so affordable you wouldn’t flinch if you lost it. Imagine it being a reliable timekeeper with a clear and easy-to-read display. That’s the essence of the Casio W86 compared to its minimalist sibling, the F105W. Both offer classic digital functionality at a bargain price, but the W86 boasts a brighter backlight and a slightly more robust build while maintaining a comfortable and stylish design.
Throughout this guide, we’ll explore their history, technical specs, design language, and user experiences to help you pick your champion Casio for everyday adventures.
History
While the exact origin stories remain a bit fuzzy, both the W86 and F105W are believed to have debuted in the mid-1990s. Following the success of the legendary F91W, these watches offered a slight evolution in design and functionality while retaining the core values of Casio – affordability and reliability.
Technical Breakdown
Under the hood, these minimalist marvels share a foundation of functionality, but the W86 boasts a few enhancements:
Movement:
Both W86 and F105W: A basic quartz movement powers both watches, keeping time reliably for years. This tried-and-true technology ensures accurate timekeeping without breaking the bank.
Materials and Construction:
| W86 | F105W |
|---|---|
| Case: Resin (lightweight, comfortable, prone to scratches) | Resin (lightweight, comfortable, prone to scratches) |
| Crystal: Acrylic (fairly scratch-resistant, can become cloudy over time) | Acrylic (fairly scratch-resistant, can become cloudy over time) |
| Band: Resin (comfortable, flexible, might feel cheap to some) | Resin (comfortable, flexible, might feel cheap to some) |
As this table highlights, both watches utilize lightweight and comfortable resin materials for the case and strap. While these materials keep the price down, they can be prone to scratches with rough use. The acrylic crystal offers decent scratch resistance but might become cloudy over time.
Functions and Features:
| Feature | W86 | F105W |
|---|---|---|
| Timekeeping | 12/24-hour format, seconds | 12/24-hour format, seconds |
| Alarm | Single daily alarm with snooze and light | Single daily alarm with snooze and light |
| Stopwatch | Measures elapsed time | Measures elapsed time |
| Backlight | Electro-luminescent (brighter white light) | Electro-luminescent (muted orange glow) |
| Water Resistance | 50 meters (5 ATM) (disputed online) | 30 meters (3 ATM) (disputed online) |
Both watches offer core functionalities like timekeeping, alarm, and stopwatch. However, the W86 shines with its brighter electro-luminescent backlight, making the display easier to read in low-light conditions. Some users actually prefer the muted orange glow of the F105W’s backlight for nighttime readability.
The water resistance ratings are officially listed as 50 meters for the W86 and 30 meters for the F105W. However, both ratings are disputed online, with some users reporting successful submersion beyond these depths. It’s always best to consult the manufacturer’s instructions and avoid pushing the limits for activities like diving.
Design and Aesthetics
Dial Design:
Both W86 and F105W: Simple negative display (dark digits on a light background) with basic timekeeping functions. Think of it as a no-frills digital readout that prioritizes clarity and easy readability.
A key differentiator lies in the overall layout:
W86: Features a slightly larger display with bolder digits. This can be beneficial for users with slightly impaired vision.
F105W: Offers a more compact display with a slightly slimmer profile. This might be ideal for those who prefer a watch that sits closer to the wrist.
Case and Bracelet:
At first glance, both the W86 and F105W appear to have identical cases and bracelets. They share the same:
Classic rectangular resin case with a simple, clean design. While comfortable, the size might feel a bit bulky on some wrists, especially the W86 due to its slightly thicker profile and larger buttons.
Matching resin strap that’s comfortable and flexible. However, some users might find it a bit cheap-looking or collect sweat easily.
Brand Image:
Both W86 and F105W: Embody the core values of Casio – affordability, reliability, and timeless design. These watches are seen as the ultimate “grab-and-go” everyday companions. The F105W, with its even slimmer profile and slightly disputed (but still decent) water resistance rating, might hold a slight edge for active lifestyles.
User Feedback
W86: Praised for its bright backlight, clear and bold display, and potentially better water resistance (although disputed online). However, the thicker case and larger buttons might feel bulky on some wrists.
F105W: Universally loved for its slim profile, classic design, muted backlight for nighttime comfort (preferred by some users), and reputation for durability. However, the dimmer backlight might be a drawback for some, and the water resistance rating (officially 30 meters) restricts its use in deeper water activities compared to the W86 (although some users report successful submersion beyond that depth).
Common Problems
Resin case and acrylic crystal: Both materials are prone to scratches with rough use. The acrylic crystal can also become cloudy over time, especially if not properly cared for.
Electro-luminescent backlight: While the W86 boasts a brighter backlight, it still might not be sufficient for very low-light conditions. The F105W’s muted backlight can be even dimmer.
Comfort: While generally comfortable, the resin strap might feel cheap to some users, and the size of the case, particularly for the W86, might be bulky on smaller wrists.
The Final Lap
So, which Casio joins your wristwatch collection? Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:
Choose the W86 if:
- You prioritize a bright and clear display for easy readability in all lighting conditions.
- You appreciate larger buttons for easier operation, especially if you have dexterity issues.
- You need a watch with potentially better water resistance for activities near water (although the rating is disputed).
Choose the F105W if:
- You value a slim profile for maximum comfort, especially on smaller wrists.
- You prefer a muted backlight for nighttime readability.
- You appreciate the classic and minimalist design of a true Casio icon.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your needs and preferences. Here’s a table summarizing the key differences:
| Feature | W86 | F105W |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Generally slightly higher | Generally slightly lower |
| Display | Larger, bolder digits | Smaller display |
| Backlight | Brighter electro-luminescent (white light) | Muted electro-luminescent (orange glow) |
| Case Thickness | Slightly thicker | Slimmer profile |
| Buttons | Larger | Smaller |
| Water Resistance | 50 meters (5 ATM) (disputed online) | 30 meters (3 ATM) (disputed online) |
| Brand Image | Clear, bold display, potentially better water resistance | Classic design, slim profile, muted backlight |
Remember, there’s no wrong answer! Both the W86 and F105W are excellent Casio timepieces, offering exceptional value for the price. Here are some additional factors to consider:
Availability: The F105W might be easier to find in stores due to its iconic status. The W86 might require searching online retailers.
Personal Style: Do you prefer a bolder look with the W86’s larger display and buttons? Or do you gravitate towards the minimalist aesthetic of the F105W?
Durability: Both watches are known for their legendary toughness. However, some users report the F105W feeling slightly sturdier due to its slimmer profile.
Battery Life: Both typically offer battery life ranging from 2 to 3 years. The actual life can vary depending on usage factors like backlight frequency.
Don’t be afraid to explore user reviews and comparisons online. Watch some video reviews to get a visual sense of the size difference between the two watches. Ultimately, the perfect Casio for you is the one that resonates most with your needs, style, and comfort preferences.
Conclusion
So, whether you choose the W86’s bright display and potentially better water resistance or the F105W’s classic design and slim profile, you’re getting a reliable and stylish digital watch. Consider your budget, desired features, wrist size, and personal preferences.
With their timeless design, legendary durability, and unbeatable value, both the W86 and F105W are guaranteed to become trusted companions on your everyday adventures, keeping you on time wherever you go.
FAQs
1. Is the W86 really water-resistant to 50 meters?
The W86 is officially rated for 50 meters of water resistance. However, there are user reports online suggesting successful submersion beyond that depth. It’s best to consult the manufacturer’s instructions and avoid pushing the limits for activities like diving.
2. Which Casio has a longer battery life?
Both the W86 and F105W typically offer battery life ranging from 2 to 3 years. The actual life can vary depending on usage factors like backlight frequency.
3. Is the W86’s backlight too bright?
The W86’s backlight is generally considered brighter than the F105W’s. While some users appreciate the clarity, others might find it a bit harsh in low-light conditions.
4. Are there any aftermarket straps available for these Casio’s?
Absolutely! Due to their immense popularity, a vast selection of aftermarket straps exists for both the W86 and F105W. You can find straps in various materials like nylon, rubber, or even metal, allowing you to personalize the look and feel of your watch.
5. Can I wear these Casios while swimming?
The W86’s 50-meter water resistance rating (if reliable) makes it suitable for swimming and snorkeling. The F105W’s 30-meter rating makes it splash-proof and okay for shallow water activities. However, avoid submerging or watching for extended periods.
So, dive into the world of affordable digital watches and choose your Casio champion! With their functionality, timeless design, and legendary durability, both the W86 and F105W are guaranteed to become trusted companions on your everyday adventures.